- Agaricocrinus acugalerus
- Agaricocrinus americanus
- Agaricocrinus attenuata
- Agaricocrinus bellatrema
- Agaricocrinus bullatus
- Agaricocrinus conicus
- Agaricocrinus convexus
- Agaricocrinus coreyi
- Agaricocrinus corrugatus
- Agaricocrinus dissimilis
- Agaricocrinus gracilis
- Agaricocrinus indianensis
- Agaricocrinus inflatus
- Agaricocrinus nodulosus
- Agaricocrinus planoconvexus
- Agaricocrinus ponderosus
- Agaricocrinus splendens
- Agaricocrinus whitfieldi
- Agaricocrinus wortheni